Interview Questions to Ask an Insurance Broker: A Hiring Manager’s Guide

Insurance brokers sit at the heart of your client relationships. They help businesses and individuals understand their risks, find the right cover and advocate for them when a claim comes through. A great broker builds loyalty that lasts for years. The wrong hire can put client relationships, insurer partnerships and your reputation at risk.  Finding…

By Charisel Dela Pena

Insurance brokers sit at the heart of your client relationships. They help businesses and individuals understand their risks, find the right cover and advocate for them when a claim comes through. A great broker builds loyalty that lasts for years. The wrong hire can put client relationships, insurer partnerships and your reputation at risk. 

Finding that person is also getting harder. Industry workforce data reported by Insurance Business shows brokers under 30 make up just 11% of the profession, the same share as those aged 60 and over, so experienced candidates are in short supply and every hiring decision counts. This guide walks you through practical questions for every stage of the interview, so you can make confident hiring decisions for your Australian insurance broking business. 

What should you look for when interviewing an insurance broker? 

Start with the technical foundations. Brokers who give advice need to meet ASIC’s RG 146 training requirements, and many will hold a Tier 1 insurance broking qualification or a Diploma of Insurance Broking. Ask about the classes of business they’ve handled, whether that’s commercial, SME, personal lines or a specialist area, and how comfortable they are explaining policy wordings, exclusions and coverage gaps to clients. 

Then look closely at how they build relationships. The best brokers combine technical knowledge with clear communication, resilience and a real interest in their clients’ businesses. They understand the Insurance Brokers Code of Practice, manage renewals proactively and stay calm when a claim gets complicated. Be clear early on whether you need a new business specialist or someone to service an existing portfolio, as the skills and motivations differ. 

What technical questions should you ask an insurance broker? 

Technical questions show whether a broker can give sound advice and manage a portfolio well. 

  • Which classes of business have you broked, and what size of clients have you looked after? 
  • How do you identify coverage gaps when reviewing a client’s existing insurance program? 
  • How do you approach the market when placing a difficult risk? 
  • How do you meet your obligations under the Insurance Brokers Code of Practice? 

How do you assess an insurance broker’s track record? 

Behavioural questions show you how a broker has performed with real clients and real insurers. Ask for specific examples and listen for numbers as well as stories. A broker who can talk confidently about their retention rate, the size of the portfolio they’ve managed and how they’ve won new business usually has a clear handle on their performance. 

  • Tell me about a time you helped a client through a difficult claim. What was your role? 
  • Describe how you retained a client who was considering moving to another broker. 
  • Give an example of new business you won and how you approached it. 

What situational questions should you ask an insurance broker? 

Situational questions test a broker’s judgement in the moments that matter most to clients. 

  • A long-standing client’s premium has increased sharply at renewal. How do you handle the conversation? 
  • An insurer declines a claim you believe should be covered. What do you do next? 
  • A client asks you to reduce their cover to save money, but you think it leaves them exposed. How do you respond? 

What red flags should you watch for when interviewing an insurance broker? 

Watch for candidates who focus on price rather than advice, or who struggle to explain cover in plain language. Be cautious if a broker promises to bring a large book of clients with them, as restraint and non-solicitation clauses often apply. Limited knowledge of the Code of Practice, poor renewal management and a habit of blaming insurers for every difficult outcome are also warning signs. 

What does a strong answer look like? 

Strong answers show the broker puts the client first. For instance, when asked about a difficult claim, a strong candidate explains what the client was facing, how they gathered the right information, how they advocated with the insurer and what the outcome was. They talk about keeping the client informed throughout and what they changed at the next renewal as a result. 

What else should you consider when interviewing an insurance broker? 

A short role play, such as a mock client meeting or renewal discussion, is a valuable addition to the process. It quickly shows how a candidate asks questions, explains options and handles objections. 

  • Do you have any restraint or non-solicitation obligations with your current employer? 
  • What size and type of portfolio are you most comfortable managing? 
  • Which insurer relationships do you value most, and why? 
  • Why are you interested in joining our business? 

Need help finding experienced insurance brokers? 

With experienced brokers in short supply, the way you approach hiring can make all the difference. We work closely with insurance brokerages and underwriting agencies across Australia and can share tailored insights on the market, salary benchmarks for broking roles and a personalised hiring guide to support your search. If you’re planning to grow your team or replace a key broker, get in touch for a conversation, wherever you are in your planning

Related Content